Necklace vs Ring: Choosing the Right Keepsake

Quick takeaways
  • ✓ Necklaces are versatile, can be worn over clothing or tucked away, and work well with glass gemstones or precious stones.
  • ✓ Rings are tactile and discreet; ideal for hidden-chamber designs within ashes jewellery.
  • ✓ Choose based on daily wear, job practicality, and whether you prefer discreet or statement pieces.

Designing your own memorial keepsake is a deeply cathartic experience. It can form an important part of the grieving process by allowing you to focus your attention onto something that will support you as you move forward.

A memorial keepsake is a piece of jewellery that contains a symbolic portion of a loved one’s ashes. It’s not a large urn that you carry around with you, but rather a small piece of comfort that can help you to feel strong in moments of deep pain.

Jewellery is a popular choice as you can wear it discreetly, and no one needs to know that you are wearing a small memorial. It’s also tactile, which means you can reach for it in moments of need. It can also form part of an outfit for a special occasion, particularly if you choose a statement piece.

In short, memorial jewellery can help you to feel connected with someone you have lost, allowing you to move forward with your grief and build the next stage of your life. Choosing the right piece of jewellery for you can be difficult. Many people will land on two pieces: either a ring or a necklace. In this guide, we’re exploring the key differences between the two, so you can decide which one is right for you.

What is a memorial keepsake necklace?

Memorial keepsake necklaces are hugely popular for those grieving the loss of a loved one. Necklaces are versatile in their design, so you can choose from a wide range of designs. This could include pendants, dog tags, simple chains, glass gemstones, diamonds and precious gemstones. The beauty of a necklace is that it can be worn visible over clothes or tucked away. This makes it an ideal choice for those looking for something discreet.

Benefits of a memorial keepsake necklace

  • Versatile choice with plenty of customisation choices
  • Can be simple and sleek or elaborate with precious gemstones or diamonds
  • Different chain lengths can be adapted to different styles
  • The necklace provides tactile comfort in a discreet way

Downsides of a memorial keepsake necklace

  • There is a risk of losing the necklace, which could be emotionally distressing
  • Those with limited mobility might struggle with the clasp
  • This choice might not be suited to a child as they might lose or break it

What is a memorial keepsake ring?

Another option for commemorating the loss of a loved one is a memorial keepsake ring. This is a piece of jewellery with a hidden compartment holding a symbolic portion of ashes of a loved one. The ring might be simple and understated, or it could include an elaborate setting with a glass gemstone, precious gemstone or a diamond.

Rings are a popular choice as they are discreet and look like any other piece of jewellery. They’re also tactile and can bring comfort in moments of difficulty. They can also be saved as occasion wear, allowing the individual to decide when they need a little extra comfort.

Benefits of a memorial keepsake ring

  • Small and discreet memorial that looks like any other piece of jewellery
  • Can be paired with a bumper ring to help prevent loss
  • Diverse range of styles available for every taste and preference
  • Can be enhanced with glass gemstones, precious stones or diamonds
  • Suitable for wedding or engagement rings

Downsides of a memorial keepsake ring

  • Not always suitable for those who work manual labour with their hands
  • Could be a visible target for thieves, particularly if it contains a diamond setting
Curious about diamonds from ashes vs glass? Diamonds made from ashes can be expensive and often appear yellow with inclusions. Many families prefer memorial glass or hidden-chamber ashes jewellery. Learn more: Memorial Glass vs Diamonds or read Things You Need To Know About Cremation Jewellery.

How to choose the right one for you

When choosing between a ring or a necklace, think about what pieces of jewellery you wear most often. If you already wear a necklace regularly, it might be better to choose a ring. It’s easy to wear multiple rings, but layering necklaces can be more difficult.

You should also think about your line of work and whether it would be practical to wear a ring or a necklace every day. If you work with your hands, you might risk damaging a ring. If you work in a dangerous environment, you might be unable to safely wear a necklace at work.

You should also consider if you plan to wear the piece every day, or if you’ll save it for special occasions. For everyday wear, a simple ring or necklace could be a huge source of emotional support. For special occasions, you might want a more elaborate and statement piece of jewellery to wear.

If you are struggling to decide between the two, it might be better to opt for both, choosing a simple design for one piece of jewellery and a statement piece for the other. This will ensure you can enjoy the best of both.

Necklace vs Ring: quick comparison

Option Benefits Considerations
Necklace Versatile; wearable over clothing or tucked; works with glass gemstones and precious stones Risk of loss; some may struggle with clasps; not ideal for children
Ring Tactile comfort; discreet; pairs with bumper ring; suited to hidden-chamber ashes jewellery Manual work can scuff/damage; diamond settings may attract attention

!